Case Study
Rethinking the Product Comparison Experience

Role
Product Designer
Domain
E-commerce
Product
High-traffic e-commerce platform for a global FMCG brand with 45M+ annual users
The Challenge
The comparison feature was hidden in the navigation, making it difficult for users to discover. On mobile, comparing products also meant navigating a long table with dense information and multiple scrolling areas.
Replacing a product was challenging because the dropdown was positioned at the top of the page and wasn’t fixed, making it easy to overlook. The existing implementation also had technical issues that prevented users from proceeding to the retailer’s website.
To understand these problems and validate potential improvements, I worked with the Product Manager on A/B testing and user testing.

UX Audit: Existing Design
Research Approach
I used analytics, A/B testing, and moderated user testing to understand how people interacted with the comparison feature and evaluate potential improvements.
Analytics: Reviewed feature engagement and the existing comparison flow.
A/B testing: Evaluated alternative approaches to the comparison experience.
User testing: Worked with the Product Manager to test product replacement flows and comparison table layouts with users from the US market.
I synthesised the findings to identify usability issues and inform the design decisions.

Test 1 — Product Replacement Options

Test 2 — Comparison Table Layout
Key Findings
01. Comparison needed to be easier to discover
Hiding the feature in the navigation made it less accessible. Users needed a more direct way to start comparing products from the catalogue.
02. Product replacement needed a clearer interaction
The dropdown at the top of the comparison page was easy to miss. A more visible, direct action could make replacing a product easier to understand.
03. The comparison table needed to support quick scanning
Users had different preferences for detailed and compact layouts. Checkmarks and crosses helped users scan feature differences, while some preferred more space and additional detail. Technical terms could also benefit from short explanations.

Additional Findings from Usability Testing
Design Solution
01. Start comparing directly from the catalogue
I moved product comparison into the catalogue, allowing users to select products using checkboxes and start comparing without searching through the navigation. A bottom sheet provided an overview of selected products and a direct way to proceed.
02. Replace products directly on the comparison page
I introduced a visible Replace button, allowing users to change a product without leaving the comparison experience.
03. Make product differences easier to scan
I redesigned the comparison layout to present product characteristics more clearly, using checkmarks and crosses to highlight differences. The layout was informed by user feedback on readability, information density, and ease of scanning.

Desktop Comparison Experience
Before & After
Before
Comparison was hidden in the navigation.
The mobile table contained dense information and required navigating multiple scrolling areas.
Product replacement relied on a dropdown at the top of the page.
Technical issues prevented users from proceeding to the retailer’s website.
After
Comparison could be started directly from the catalogue.
A bottom sheet displayed selected products and provided a clear entry point to comparison.
A visible Replace button enabled product changes directly on the comparison page.
The redesigned experience supported clearer product comparison and a working transition to the retailer’s website.
Redesigned Comparison Flow
Outcomes
The redesigned experience made product comparison easier to discover and improved engagement with the feature.
Feature engagement: increased by 120% after comparison became accessible directly from the catalogue instead of being hidden in the navigation.
Time to compare two products: decreased from approximately 2 min 40 sec to 55 sec.
Retailer click-through rate: increased from 0 to 300+ among users who opened Compare Products.
I reviewed the results three months after release. The retailer click-through improvement also reflected the resolution of technical issues that had previously prevented users from proceeding to the retailer’s website.
Learnings
This project reinforced the importance of making key features discoverable at the point of need. It also showed how small interaction changes, such as replacing a hard-to-notice dropdown with a clear action, can reduce friction in a user flow.
Combining analytics with user feedback helped me evaluate both the effectiveness of the experience and the usability issues behind the numbers.

